Texas passed a Bible-themed curriculum. But many districts aren’t using it

k9bmkDEC@?8m%6I2D A2DD65 2 q:3=6\E96>65 4FCC:4F=F>] qFE >2?J 5:DEC:4ED 2C6?’E FD:?8 :Ek^DEC@?8mk^9bm

kAm%9:D 4@>:?8 D49@@= J62C[ E96 u2:C7:6=5[ %6I2D[ D49@@= 5:DEC:4E[ 23@FE 92=7H2J 36EH66? s2==2D 2?5 w@FDE@?[ H:== C@== @FE 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E96fc>:==:@?]@C8^2CE:4=6^:?\4=@D6\G@E6\E6I2D\2AAC@G6D\C625:?8\AC@8C2>\=256?\H:E9\3:3=6\=6DD@?D^Qm?6H z\d C625:?8 AC@8C2>k^2m E92E :?4=F56D >F=E:A=6 3:3=:42= C676C6?46D[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E96fc>:==:@?]@C8^Qm%96 fck^2m C6A@CED]k^Am

kAmqFE E96 DE277[ 9@A:?8 E@ 2G@:5 5632E6D @G6C 72>:=:6D’ C6=:8:@FD 36=:67D[ 92D 49@AA65 C@F89=J b_ D64E:@?D @FE @7 E96 4FCC:4F=F>[ :?4=F5:?8 2 <:?56C82CE6? =6DD@? @? E96 v@=56? #F=6 762EFC:?8 y6DFD’ $6C>@? @? E96 |@F?E 2?5 D6G6C2= 6I46CAED 23@FE 2 r9C:DE:2? AC2J6C E96 8@G6C?@C @7 !=J>@FE9 r@=@?J D2:5 2E E96 7:CDE %92?<D8:G:?8]k^Am

kAm%96 5:DEC:4E’D 6=6>6?E2CJ E62496CD “H6?E E9C@F89 E96 >2E6C:2=D =@@<:?8 7@C E9:?8D E92E >2J 36 4@?EC@G6CD:2=[” D2:5 $FA6C:?E6?56?E y@6 rC2:8] %96J 5:5?’E 766= E9@D6 A2CED @7 E96 4FCC:4F=F> “H6C6 :? =:?6 H:E9 H92E H6 H2?E65 E96 =6DD@? E@ 7@4FD @?]”k^Am

kAmu2:C7:6=5’D AC@46DD C67=64ED E96 <:?5 @7 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]<D2E]4@>^?6HD^=@42=^a_ad^_c^_h^H9:49\D2?\2?E@?:@\5:DEC:4ED\2C6\25@AE:?8\E96\DE2E6D\3:3=6\:?7FD65\3=F63@??6E\=62C?:?8\4FCC:4F=F>^QmD6=64E:G6 2AAC@249k^2m E92E >2?J 5:DEC:4ED 92G6 E2<6? E@H2C5 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^E62]E6I2D]8@G^24256>:4D^:?DECF4E:@?2=\>2E6C:2=D^3=F63@??6E\=62C?:?8Qmq=F63@??6E {62C?:?8k^2m — E96 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E96fc>:==:@?]@C8^2CE:4=6^H9@\HC@E6\E6I2DD\>:==:@?\5@==2C\3:3=6\:?7FD65\4FCC:4F=F>\E96\DE2E6\H@?E\D2J^QmDE2E6\56G6=@A65 >2E6C:2=Dk^2m E92E AC@>:?6?E=J 762EFC6 E96 q:3=6 2?5 r9C:DE:2?:EJ] (:E9 7665324< 7C@> b__ E62496CD[ u@CE (@CE9[ E96 7:7E9 =2C86DE 5:DEC:4E :? E96 DE2E6[ 25@AE65 E96 A9@?:4D A@CE:@? @7 E96 4FCC:4F=F>[ 3FE EFC?65 5@H? E96 F?:ED H:E9 C6=:8:@FD >2E6C:2=] $@>6 5:DEC:4ED @C56C65 ;FDE 2 76H 3@@<D[ =:<6=J 7@C k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]9@FDE@?AF3=:4>65:2]@C8^2CE:4=6D^?6HD^7@CE\36?5^a_ad^_b^ad^d`eg`d^7@CE\36?5\:D5\3@2C5\2AAC@G6D\3=F63@??6E\=62C?:?8\4FCC:4F=F>\D2>A=6\D6E\56DA:E6\@AA@D:E:@?^RiOiE6IElu@CETa_q6?5\[u@CETa_q6?5Ta_x$sTa_3@2C5Ta_2AAC@G6DTa_D2>A=6Ta_D6ETa_@7Ta_q:3=6Tas:?7FD65[=6DD@?Ta_A=2?DTa_7@CTa_6=6>6?E2CJTa_DEF56?ED]QmC6G:6H AFCA@D6Dk^2m[ H9:=6 E96 w@FDE@? 2?5 s2==2D 5:DEC:4ED @AE65 E@ <66A H92E E96J 4FCC6?E=J FD6]k^Am

kAm%6I2D 92D DA6?E C@F89=J S`__ >:==:@? — 2?5 4@F?E:?8 — E@ 56G6=@A 2?5 AC@>@E6 :ED @H? C625:?8 4FCC:4F=F>] qFE D@>6 @3D6CG6CD D2J E96J H@F=5?’E 36 DFCAC:D65 :7 5:DEC:4ED 2C6?’E CFD9:?8 E@ A:4< :E FA[ 4@?D:56C:?8 E96 $E2E6 q@2C5 @7 t5F42E:@? 2AAC@G65 :E 3J 2 @?6\G@E6 >2C8:?]k^Am

kAm“%96J >2J 36 C6=F4E2?E E@ 3C:?8 E92E D2>6 4@?EC@G6CDJ :?E@ E96:C 5:DEC:4ED[ 6DA64:2==J :? 4@>>F?:E:6D H:E9 72>:=:6D @7 5:G6CD6 C6=:8:@FD 324<8C@F?5D[” D2:5 tG6 |J6CD[ 2 4@?DF=E2?E H:E9 $EC:G6 !F3=:4 !@=:4J #6D@FC46D[ 2 A@=:E:42= 4@?DF=E:?8 2?5 =@33J:?8 7:C> E92E :D EC24<:?8 25@AE:@? @7 E96 AC@8C2>] “xE’D A@E6?E:2==J 2 5:DEC24E:@? 7C@> E96:C 7@4FD @? E96 3F586E[ DEF56?E 249:6G6>6?E[ D49@@= D276EJ[ 2?5 2== E96 @E96C AC6DD:?8 :DDF6D E96J >FDE 255C6DD]”k^Am

kAm%6I2D 92D @G6C `[a__ 5:DEC:4ED 2?5 23@FE e__ 492CE6C D49@@=D H:E9 6=6>6?E2CJ 8C256D] ~7 E96 DE2E6’D a_ =2C86DE 5:DEC:4ED[ @?=J r@?C@6[ ?@CE9 @7 w@FDE@?[ :?E6?5D E@ FD6 E96 AC@8C2> E9:D 72==] p k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^E62]E6I2D]8@G^24256>:4D^:?DECF4E:@?2=\>2E6C:2=D^AF3=:D96CDQmDE2E6 AFC492D:?8 DJDE6>k^2m D9@HD E92E 36EH66? |2J 2?5 =2E6 yF=J[ `cc 5:DEC:4ED 2?5 492CE6CD[ >@DE=J >:5\D:K65 @C D>2==[ @C56C65 E96 >2E6C:2=D]k^Am

kAm$E2E6 3@2C5 >6>36CD 92G6 2D<65 7@C E96 E@E2= ?F>36C @7 5:DEC:4ED FD:?8 q=F63@??6E] “%92E’D E96 BF6DE:@? H6 H@F=5 2== =:<6 E@ <?@H[” D2:5 !2> {:EE=6[ 2 3@2C5 >6>36C H9@ G@E65 282:?DE E96 C625:?8 AC@8C2> =2DE }@G6>36C]k^Am

kAm~E96C 5:DEC:4ED 4@F=5 36 FD:?8 E96 @?=:?6 G6CD:@? @7 E96 >2E6C:2=D[ 3FE H96E96C DEF56?ED H@F=5 92G6 24EF2= 3@@<D 2?5 DA6?5 =6DD E:>6 @? D4C66?D[ H2D 2 >2;@C 5632E6 =2DE J62C 5FC:?8 E96 3@2C5’D 4@?D:56C2E:@? @7 E96 AC@8C2>]k^Am

kAm$E2E6 =6256CD 2?5 4@?D6CG2E:G6 25G@42E6D D2J E96 C6=:8:@FD 4@?E6?E C67=64ED 2 4=2DD:42= 2?5 2AAC@AC:2E6 H2J E@ E6249 =:E6C24J D<:==D 2=@?8 H:E9 9:DE@CJ 2?5 4F=EFC6] ~E96CD =:<6 E96 6>A92D:D @? 4FCD:G6 HC:E:?8 2?5 492==6?8:?8 G@423F=2CJ] x? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E96fc>:==:@?]@C8^2CE:4=6^6I4=FD:G6\E6I2D\D66<D\E@\:?;64E\3:3=6\DE@C:6D\:?E@\6=6>6?E2CJ\D49@@=\C625:?8\AC@8C2>^Qm2? :?E6CG:6Hk^2m H:E9 %96 fc =2DE J62C[ $E2E6 r@>>:DD:@?6C @7 t5F42E:@? |:<6 |@C2E9 D2:5 2 A9@?:4D\32D65 4FCC:4F=F> E92E 2=D@ 3F:=5D DEF56?ED’ 324<8C@F?5 <?@H=6586 42? 96=A E96 DE2E6 C64@G6C 7C@> k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]EAC]@C8^65F42E:@?^a_ad\_`\ah^E6I2D\D4@C6D\A@@C=J\@?\E96\?2E:@?D\C6A@CE\42C5\C625:?8\D4@C6D\=@H6DE\:?\564256DQm564=:?6Dk^2m :? C625:?8 D<:==D 5F6 E@ E96 A2?56>:4]k^Am

kAmqFE E96 AC@8C2> DA2C<65 2 DE2E6H:56 5632E6 @G6C H96E96C A@=:E:42= =6256CD 2C6 7@C4:?8 r9C:DE:2?:EJ :?E@ AF3=:4 D49@@=D] q=F63@??6E >2<6D :ED 563FE :? E96 4=2DDC@@> 2E E96 D2>6 E:>6 D49@@=D H:== 36 C6BF:C65[ F?56C 2 ?6H DE2E6 =2H[ E@ 5:DA=2J E96 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E96fc>:==:@?]@C8^2CE:4=6^DE2E6\=2HD\C6BF:C:?8\E6?\4@>>2?5>6?ED\:?\D49@@=D\2C6\E96\AC@5F4E\@7\2\72C\C:89E\3:==\>:==^Qm`_ r@>>2?5>6?EDk^2m] v@G] vC68 p33@EE 2=D@ D:8?65 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^42A:E@=]E6I2D]8@G^E=@5@4D^gh#^3:==E6IE^A57^$q___``x]A57R?2GA2?6Dl_Qm=68:D=2E:@?k^2m :? yF?6 E92E 2==@HD 5:DEC:4ED E@ @776C 2 52:=J[ G@=F?E2CJ A6C:@5 @7 E:>6 E@ AC2J 2?5 C625 E96 q:3=6 @C @E96C C6=:8:@FD E6IED] &?56C 2 D:>:=2C a_ab =2H[ 5:DEC:4ED 42? 9:C6 492A=2:?D E@ G@=F?E66C 2D 4@F?D6=@CD[ 3FE k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]DE2E6D>2?]4@>^DE@CJ^?6HD^65F42E:@?^a_ad^_b^af^E6I2D\492A=2:?D\D49@@=\4@F?D6=@CD\9@H\D49@@=D\G@E65\2446AE\C6;64E^gaebbhcb__f^Qm>@DE 5:DEC:4EDk^2m 2C6?’E A2CE:4:A2E:?8]k^Am

kAm“%96C6 :D 567:?:E6=J 2 5:D4@??64E 36EH66? E96 C25:42= 72C C:89E 286?52 … 2?5 H92E D49@@= 3@2C5D H9@ 2C6 244@F?E23=6 E@ =@42= 72>:=:6D 2?5 DEF56?ED 2C6 24EF2==J 8@:?8 E@ 5@[” D2:5 vFE9C:6 vC2G6D\u:EKD:>>@?D[ D6?:@C 5:C64E@C @7 A@=:4J 2?5 25G@424J 2E E96 x?E6C72:E9 p==:2?46[ 2 ?2E:@?2= 8C@FA E92E 25G@42E6D 7@C 49FC49\DE2E6 D6A2C2E:@?] %6I2D[ 96 D2:5[ :D “E2<:?8 2H2J E96 C:89ED @7 4=6C8J 2?5 A2C6?ED E@ =625 C6=:8:@FD :?DECF4E:@?]”k^Am

kAmx? E96 fb[___\DEF56?E r@?C@6 D49@@= 5:DEC:4E[ s2JC6? r2C=:D=6[ 2 4FCC:4F=F> 5:C64E@C[ D2:5 =6256CD A:4<65 q=F63@??6E 3642FD6 E62496CD H6C6 AC6G:@FD=J H@C<:?8 H:E9 2 A2E49H@C< @7 >2E6C:2=D] %96J @7E6? DA6?E “2C5F@FD 9@FCD AC6A2C:?8 7@C C625:?8 2?5 HC:E:?8 :?DECF4E:@?[” D96 E@=5 %96 fc :? 2? 6>2:=] q=F63@??6E AC@G:56D 2 4@96C6?E D6E @7 =6DD@?D E92E >66E DE2E6 DE2?52C5D[ D96 D2:5]k^Am

kAmqFE A2C6?E r9C:DE:?6 *2E6D 25G@42E65 282:?DE :E]k^Am

kAm“x 5@?’E E9:?< C6=:8:@FD\32D65 :?DECF4E:@? 36=@?8D :? 2?J EJA6 @7 AF3=:4 D49@@= D6EE:?8[” D2:5 *2E6D[ H9@D6 49:=5C6? H:== 36 :? D64@?5 2?5 7@FCE9 8C256 E9:D 72==] w6C 72>:=J 5@6D?’E 2EE6?5 49FC49[ 2?5 D96’D 4@?46C?65 E92E E96 =6DD@?D 562=:?8 H:E9 72:E9 2C6 ;FDE “3@CC@H:?8 EC@F3=6]”k^Am

kAmq64<J $96CC:==[ 2 7@C>6C r@?C@6 E62496C[ DJ>A2E9:K6D H:E9 65F42E@CD H9@ H:== 92G6 E@ ?2G:82E6 A2C6?ED’ C6BF6DED E@ @AE E96:C 49:=5C6? @FE @7 E96 =6DD@?D] xE’D 2 C:89E E92E >2?J A2C6?ED >:89E 36 >@C6 =:<6=J E@ 6I6C4:D6 E9:D 72== 3642FD6 @7 2 yF?6 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E96fc>:==:@?]@C8^2CE:4=6^DFAC6>6\4@FCE\C6BF:C6D\D49@@=D\E@\2==@H\DEF56?ED\E@\@AE\@FE\@7\=83EB\=6DD@?D^Qm&]$] $FAC6>6 r@FCE @A:?:@?k^2m :? 72G@C @7 C6=:8:@FD 72>:=:6D H9@ H2?E E96:C 49:=5C6? 6I6>AE65 7C@> 962C:?8 DE@C:6D H:E9 {vq%" E96>6D]k^Am

kAm“xE’D 92C5 @? E96 E62496C] xE’D 2=C625J D@ 92C5 2E r9C:DE>2D @C 6G6? H:E9 3:CE952JD[” $96CC:== D2:5[ C676CC:?8 E@ y69@G29’D (:E?6DD6D D96 92D 925 2D DEF56?ED] “*@F 42?’E 8:G6 D@>6 <:5D 4FA42<6D 3642FD6 E96J 5@?’E 46=63C2E6 3:CE952JD]”k^Am

kAm$96’D 2=C625J 9@>6D49@@=:?8 96C >:55=6 D49@@= D@? 2?5 92D AF==65 96C 52F89E6C[ 2 7:7E9 8C256C[ @FE @7 E96 5:DEC:4E 2D H6==[ =2C86=J 3642FD6 @7 q=F63@??6E 2?5 E96 `_ r@>>2?5>6?ED =2H]k^Am

kAmpE 2 |2J 3@2C5 >66E:?8[ r2C=:D=6 6IA=2:?65 E@ E96 3@2C5 9@H E62496CD H:== 7:6=5 C6BF6DED 7C@> A2C6?ED H9@ H2?E E@ @AE E96:C 49:=5C6? @FE @7 E96 =6DD@?D]k^Am

kAm“x7 2 A2C6?E H6C6 E@ 4@>A=2:? 23@FE E9:D … H6 H@F=5 92G6 E@ 7:?5 2 4@>A=6E6=J 5:776C6?E E6IE[” D96 D2:5]k^Am

kAmqFE E92E 5:5?’E D:E H6== H:E9 %:772?J q2F>2?? }6=D@?[ @?6 @7 E9C66 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]49C@?]4@>^?6HD^9@FDE@?\E6I2D^2CE:4=6^>2>2\362CD\4@?C@6\:D5\`hhccegb]A9AQm4@?D6CG2E:G6 D49@@= 3@2C5 >6>36CDk^2m[ H9@ 42== E96>D6=G6D |2>2 q62CD[ 6=64E65 :? a_aa]k^Am

kAm“%96C6 :D ?@ C6=:8:@? :? E9:D 4FCC:4F=F>[” D96 2C8F65] “%96J’C6 2== 9:DE@C:42= C676C6?46D[ 2?5 D@ :? >J @A:?:@?[ E96C6 D9@F=5 36 ?@ 2=E6C?2E:G6 @C >@5:7:42E:@?D]”k^Am

kAm(96E96C 5:DEC:4ED 2C6 C6>@G:?8 3:3=:42= >2E6C:2= @C A2C6?ED 2C6 @AE:?8 E96:C 49:=5C6? @FE @7 E96 =6DD@?D[ {:EE=6[ E96 DE2E6 3@2C5 >6>36C[ H@CC:6D DEF56?ED 4@F=5 >:DD =:E6C24J D<:==D E96J 2C6 DFAA@D65 E@ =62C?]k^Am

kAm“$2J 2? t2DE pD:2? C6=:8:@FD A2C6?E 92D 564:565 E96J 5@?’E H2?E E96:C 49:=5 E@ 92G6 ,2 q:3=6 DE@CJ.] xD E92E 49:=5 8@:?8 E@ >:DD D<:== 56G6=@A>6?En” D96 2D<65] p44@>>@52E:?8 A2C6?ED’ C6BF6DED H:== 2=D@ 36 2 3FC56? @? 5:DEC:4E DE277] “(92E :D E96 4@DE :?G@=G65 :? E96 >2?A@H6C E:>6 7@C E96D6 5:DEC:4ED E@ 8@ E9C@F89 2?5 6=:>:?2E6 E96 C6=:8:@FD 4@?E6?En %96C6 H2D ?@ ?665 7@C E96 4@?EC@G6CDJ E92E E96 C6=:8:@FD 4@?E6?E :D 8@:?8 E@ DE2CE]”k^Am

kAm%96 DE2E6 3@2C5 ?2CC@H=J 2AAC@G65 E96 ?6H AC@8C2> =2DE 72== 27E6C E96 %6I2D t5F42E:@? p86?4J DA6?E C@F89=J Sgc >:==:@? E@ 252AE 2? 6I:DE:?8 C625:?8 4FCC:4F=F>[ 7C@> E96 4@>A2?J p>A=:7J] #6?2>65 q=F63@??6E[ 27E6C E96 DE2E6 7=@H6C[ E96 %6I2D G6CD:@? :?4=F56D 9:89=:89ED @7 y6DFD’ >:?:DECJ 2?5 @776CD 2? 6G2?86=:42= G:6H @7 62C=J p>6C:42? 9:DE@CJ] {6DD@?D 7@C 6I2>A=6[ :?4=F56 E96 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^E62=62C?]:?DECF4EFC6]4@>^4@FCD6D^hdch^A286D^F?:E\`\E62496C\8F:56n>@5F=60:E6>0:5lfbfc_b_QmA2C23=6 @7 E96 !C@5:82= $@?k^2m[ 2? 2CE 9:DE@CJ F?:E 32D65 @? E96 4C62E:@? DE@CJ 7C@> v6?6D:D 2?5 D4C:AEFC2= C676C6?46D E@ E96 >@EE@ @? E96 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^E62=62C?]:?DECF4EFC6]4@>^4@FCD6D^hdch^A286D^F?:E\g\E62496C\8F:56n>@5F=60:E6>0:5lfbfc`c_Qm{:36CEJ q6==k^2m]k^Am

kAm%96 286?4J[ H9:49 H@F=5 ?@E AC@G:56 2 =:DE @7 2== 5:DEC:4ED E92E 92G6 @C56C65 E96 AC@8C2>[ A2:5 >F=E:A=6 4@>A2?:6D 2?5 4@?E6?E 6IA6CED E@ 4C27E 2?5 C6G:6H E96 =6DD@?D[ :?4=F5:?8 E96 72C\C:89E %6I2D !F3=:4 !@=:4J u@F?52E:@?] w:==D52=6 r@==686[ 2 r9C:DE:2? D49@@= :? |:49:82?[ G@=F?E66C65 E@ H@C< @? F?:ED C6=2E65 E@ p>6C:42’D 7@F?5:?8[ 2?5 2 r9C:DE:2? >65:2 4@>A2?J[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E96fc>:==:@?]@C8^2CE:4=6^>:<6\9F4<2366D\72:E9\32D65\>65:2\4@>A2?J\4@?EC:3FE65\E@\?6H\E6I2D\4FCC:4F=F>^Qm4@\7@F?565 3J |:<6 wF4<2366[k^2m &]$] 2>32DD25@C E@ xDC26=[ 4@?EC:3FE65 :==FDEC2E:@?D] qFE %6I2D @77:4:2=D C67FD65 E@ :56?E:7J k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E96fc>:==:@?]@C8^2CE:4=6^H9@\HC@E6\E6I2DD\>:==:@?\5@==2C\3:3=6\:?7FD65\4FCC:4F=F>\E96\DE2E6\H@?E\D2J^QmH9@ HC@E6 E96 3:3=:42= A2DD286Dk^2m]k^Am

kAmx? C6DA@?D6 E@ 324<=2D9[ @77:4:2=D 25565 >@C6 C676C6?46D E@ xD=2> 2?5 w:?5F:D>[ 2?5 C6>@G65 D@>6 E6IED E92E H6C6 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E96fc>:==:@?]@C8^2CE:4=6^E6I2D\;6HD\D2J\DE2E6D\?6H\3:3=6\:?7=F6?465\4FCC:4F=F>\:D\H:=5=J\AC@3=6>2E:4^Qm@776?D:G6 E@ y6HDk^2m[ 3FE E96 7:?2= G6CD:@? DE:== C676C6?46D r9C:DE:2?:EJ >@C6 E92? @E96C C6=:8:@?D]k^Am

kAm“(6 C6G:6H65 :E 2?5 =@G65 :E[” D2:5 r:?5: r2DE:==2[ AC6D:56?E @7 E96 %6I2D t28=6 u@CF>[ 2 4@?D6CG2E:G6 @C82?:K2E:@?] $96 AFD965 7@C DE2E6 3@2C5 2AAC@G2= @7 E96 4FCC:4F=F> =2DE J62C[ D2J:?8 E92E E96C6 :D “C:49?6DD :? 3:3=:42= =:E6C2EFC6” 2?5 E92E q:3=6 DE@C:6D E6249 49:=5C6? 492C24E6C EC2:ED 2?5 E96 @C:8:?D @7 E96 =682= DJDE6>]k^Am

kAm$:?46 E96?[ D96 6I2>:?65 E96 7:?2= G6CD:@? H:E9 C6E:C65 65F42E@CD H9@ 92G6 6IA6C:6?46 E6249:?8 2 4=2DD:42= 4FCC:4F=F> 2?5 E9:?<D :E H:== DEC6?8E96? DEF56?ED’ 4FCD:G6 2?5 A9@?:4D D<:==D] %92E’D H9J v:?2 tF32?< H:D96D 96C 8C2?549:=5C6?’D D49@@= 5:DEC:4ED — z2EJ[ ?62C w@FDE@?[ 2?5 q6=E@?[ ?62C (24@ — 925 25@AE65 E96 >2E6C:2=D]k^Am

kAm“x H2E4965 … 7@FCE9\ 2?5 D:IE9\8C256 9@?@C DEF56?ED HC:E6 2 E92?< J@F ?@E6 2?5 H2D D9@4<65 3J H92E x D2H — E96 =24< @7 =68:3=6 92?5HC:E:?8 2?5 E96 9@CC:7:4 DA6==:?8[” D96 D2:5]k^Am

kAms:DEC:4ED @? E96 76?46 23@FE q=F63@??6E 42? C64@?D:56C E96:C 564:D:@? ?6IE J62C] %@ >2<6 :E >@C6 6?E:4:?8[ =2H>2<6CD 25565 7:?2?4:2= :?46?E:G6D — FA E@ Se_ A6C DEF56?E 7@C 5:DEC:4ED E92E FD6 DE2E6\2AAC@G65 >2E6C:2=D] %92E H2D =:<6=J @?6 C62D@? H9J E96 af[___\DEF56?E {F33@4< D49@@=D 25@AE65 :E[ D2:5 r=:?E@? v:==[ 2 7@C>6C >2E9 2?5 D4:6?46 E62496C :? E96 5:DEC:4E H9@ ?@H H@C<D 7@C E96 %6I2D $E2E6 %62496CD pDD@4:2E:@?]k^Am

kAmpE E96 D2>6 E:>6[ 96 E9:?<D 5:DEC:4E =6256CD 2DDF>6 DEF56?ED H:== DE2?5 2 36EE6C 492?46 @7 A6C7@C>:?8 H6== @? E96 DE2E6 E6DE :7 @77:4:2=D >2E49 :E FA E@ 2 4FCC:4F=F> E96 DE2E6 56G6=@A65] p5@AE:?8 q=F63@??6E “2=D@ 96=AD E96 5:DEC:4E ?@E 92G6 E@ 9:C6 DE277 E@ HC:E6 4FCC:4F=F> H96? E96J 86E :E 7C@> E96 DE2E6 7@C 7C66]”k^Am

kAm%96 A6C\DEF56?E 3@?FD :D?’E E96 @?=J H2J E96 DE2E6 2:>D E@ 6?DFC6 q=F63@??6E 364@>6D E96 AC676CC65 49@:46] x? s646>36C[ E96 >@?E9 27E6C E96 3@2C5 2AAC@G65 :E[ E96 %6I2D t5F42E:@? p86?4J BF:4<=J >256 q=F63@??6E 2G2:=23=6 E@ @C56C] |2E6C:2=D 7C@> @E96C AF3=:D96CD H6C6?’E 2G2:=23=6 F?E:= |2J]k^Am

kAm“xE D66>D E92E q=F63@??6E {62C?:?8 925 2? 25G2?E286[” {:EE=6 E@=5 |@C2E9[ E96 4@>>:DD:@?6C[ 5FC:?8 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]25>:?>@?:E@C]4@>^EI^E62^4@>>:EE660@70E9607F==03@2C5^a_ad_ead^Qm2 yF?6 >66E:?8k^2m] $96 D2:5 D96 962C5 4@>A=2:?ED 7C@> AF3=:D96CD @G6C E96 :DDF6]k^Am

kAm|@C2E9 42==65 E96 56=2J 2 “@?6\E:>6 6I246C32E65 AC@3=6>” 3642FD6 E96 DE2E6 925 E@ 255 ?6H =2?8F286 E@ 4@?EC24ED H:E9 AF3=:D96CD 367@C6 >2<:?8 E96:C >2E6C:2=D 2G2:=23=6 E@ 5:DEC:4ED] (9:=6 E96 E:>6 =2AD6 D9@F=5 36 D9@CE6C ?6IE J62C[ 96 D2:5 E96C6 H@F=5 2=H2JD 36 D@>6 82A]k^Am

kAmx? E96 4FCC6?E k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^=68:D42?]4@>^%)^E6IE^wqa^:5^bachbbbQmDE2E6 3F586Ek^2m[ =2H>2<6CD 2FE9@C:K65 |@C2E9 E@ 4@?EC24E H:E9 3FD:?6DD6D E@ “AC@>@E6[ >2C<6E[ 2?5 25G6CE:D6” q=F63@??6E] p k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^=68:D42?]4@>^%)^E6IE^wqd__^:5^bachbc_QmD6A2C2E6 2AAC@AC:2E:@?D 3:==k^2m AC@G:56D Sacb >:==:@? E@ 5:DEC:4ED E@ 96=A H:E9 :>A=6>6?E2E:@? 4@DED[ =:<6 4@249:?8 7@C E62496CD]k^Am

kAm{2DE J62C’D 3F586E :?4=F565 S`_ >:==:@? 7@C C68:@?2= 65F42E:@? D6CG:46 46?E6CD E@ 5@ D:>:=2C H@C< 7@C 5:DEC:4ED 25@AE:?8 q=F63@??6E] %96 46?E6CD 2C6 6IA64E65 E@ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^E62c2G42DEC@]E62]DE2E6]EI]FD^6vC2?ED^ab\ac^ac_b`_dh^AC@8F:56]A57Qm>66E E2C86EDk^2m 7@C :?4C62D:?8 E96 ?F>36C @7 5:DEC:4ED FD:?8 E96 >2E6C:2=D :? E96:C C68:@? E@ DE2J 6=:8:3=6 7@C 7FEFC6 7F?5:?8]k^Am

kAm$@>6 =6256CD :? E96 DE2E6 D2J E92E E@A\5@H? AC6DDFC6 4@F=5 2=E6C E96 C6=2E:@?D9:A E96 46?E6CD 92G6 EC25:E:@?2==J 925 H:E9 D49@@= DJDE6>D :? E96:C C68:@?D] %96J 96=A 5:DEC:4ED[ 6DA64:2==J D>2==6C @?6D H:E9 76H6C 46?EC2= @77:46 DE277[ DE2J :? 4@>A=:2?46 H:E9 DE2E6 C68F=2E:@?D @C H@C< @? D49@@= :>AC@G6>6?E]k^Am

kAm%96 D6CG:46 46?E6CD 92G6 2=H2JD 366? 2 “9F3 @7 <?@H=6586[” D2:5 |2CE92 $2=2K2C\+2>@C2[ DFA6C:?E6?56?E @7 E96 %@>32== x?56A6?56?E $49@@= s:DEC:4E[ ?@CE9 @7 w@FDE@?] tIA64E:?8 5:DEC:4ED E@ D6== q=F63@??6E[ D96 D2:5[ “92D 366? >@C6 @7 2 DEC2E68:4 AFD9]”k^Am

kAm$96 5@6D?’E 5@F3E E92E q=F63@??6E H:== 3@@DE C625:?8 D4@C6D 7@C D@>6 DEF56?ED[ 3FE %@>32== :D 2=C625J C2E65 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E@>32==:D5]?6E^23@FE\E:D5^56A2CE>6?ED^4@>>F?:42E:@?D^?6HD\C6=62D6D^?6HD\56E2:=D^O3@2C5^24256>:4D^A@DE^E@>32==\:D5\62C?D\2\C2E:?8\2D\E62\C6=62D6D\56=2J65\a_ab\244@F?E23:=:EJ\C2E:?8DRiOiE6IElr@>>F?:42E:@?DTa_Tbt\[%@>32==Ta_x$sTa_t2C?DTa_TtaTg_ThrpTtaTg_ThsTa_#2E:?8Ta_2DTa_%tpTa_#6=62D6DTa_s6=2J65Ta_a_ab[:?Ta_DA64:7:4Ta_2C62DTarTa_DF49Ta_2DiQm9:89\A6C7@C>:?8 5:DEC:4Ek^2m :? E96 DE2E6’D 244@F?E23:=:EJ DJDE6>] p?@E96C C62D@? H9J D96 5:5?’E 4@?D:56C E96 AC@8C2> :D 3642FD6 2 $A2?:D9 G6CD:@? :D ?@E J6E 2G2:=23=6] w6C 5:DEC:4E[ H96C6 23@FE bdT @7 DEF56?ED 2C6 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^D49@@=D]E6I2DEC:3F?6]@C8^5:DEC:4ED^E@>32==\:D5^Qmt?8=:D9 =62C?6CDk^2m[ 92D 2 $A2?:D9\t?8=:D9 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E@>32==:D5]?6E^23@FE\E:D5^56A2CE>6?ED^24256>:4D^>F=E:=:?8F2=^EH@\H2J\5F2=\=2?8F286Qm5F2= =2?8F286 AC@8C2>k^2m]k^Am

kAm“x =@G6 2?JE9:?8 E92E 96=AD <:5D[” D96 D2:5] “x ;FDE 5@?’E E9:?< :E’D E96 C:89E E@@= 7@C 6G6CJ 5:DEC:4E]”k^Am

kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E96fc>:==:@?]@C8^2CE:4=6^E6I2D\A2DD65\2\3:3=6\E96>65\4FCC:4F=F>\3FE\>2?J\5:DEC:4ED\2C6?E\FD:?8\:E^Qmk6>m%9:D DE@CJk^6>mk^2m k6>mH2D AC@5F465 3Jk^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E96fc>:==:@?]@C8Qmk6>m%96 fck^6>mk^2m k6>m2?5 C6G:6H65 2?5 5:DEC:3FE65 3Jk^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9F3D]=2^"_b<=8$#_Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQmk6>m$E24<6Ck^6>mk^2m]k^Am