‘Failing our kids’: Philadelphia’s struggle highlights how young learners nationwide miss out on legally mandated support services

k9bmkDEC@?8m‘u2:=:?8 @FC <:5D’i !9:=256=A9:2’D DECF88=6 9:89=:89ED 9@H J@F?8 =62C?6CD ?2E:@?H:56 >:DD @FE @? =682==J >2?52E65 DFAA@CE D6CG:46Dk^DEC@?8mk^9bm

kAm(96? z:>36C=J w2=6GJ’D D@? y@D9F2 H2D E9C66[ D96 DE2CE65 962C:?8 7C@> 9:D AC6D49@@= E92E 96 H2D 24E:?8 @FE] w6 C2C6=J A2CE:4:A2E65 :? 4:C4=6 E:>6 2?5 925 EC@F3=6 A=2J:?8 H:E9 @E96C <:5D]k^Am

kAmw2=6GJ’D 7C:6?5 925 C646?E=J @A6?65 E96 AC6D49@@=[ 2?5 D96 =:<65 E92E D@>6@?6 D96 <?6H E@@< 42C6 @7 96C D@?] qFE 6G6?EF2==J[ E96 AC6D49@@= D2:5 :E H@F=5 @?=J 2==@H 9:> 324< :7 96 925 2 @?6\E@\@?6 2:56 E@ 255C6DD 9:D “5:DCFAE:G6” 3692G:@C[ w2=6GJ D2:5]k^Am

kAmpE 7:CDE[ w2=6GJ E9@F89E 86EE:?8 9:> E92E 2:56 H@F=5 36 DEC2:89E7@CH2C5] qFE D96 ?@H 56D4C:36D E96 677@CE E@ 86E 96C <:5 DFAA@CE E9C@F89 !9:=256=A9:2’D 7656C2==J >2?52E65[ AF3=:4=J 7F?565 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? DJDE6> 2D 6I92FDE:?8]k^Am

kAm%9@F89 DE2E6 6G2=F2E@CD 7@F?5 y@D9F2 D9@F=5 C646:G6 >F=E:A=6 7@C>D @7 E96C2AJ 6249 H66<[ :E E@@< >@?E9D 7@C 2?J D6CG:46D E@ 368:?[ w2=6GJ D2:5] %96?[ @?46 AC@G:56CD 4@?E24E65 96C[ D96 D2:5 :E 3642>6 2 “8F6DD:?8 82>6” H96E96C 96C D@? H@F=5 C646:G6 E96 9@>6\32D65 @44FA2E:@?2= E96C2AJ 2?5 DA64:2=:K65 :?DECF4E:@? 96 BF2=:7:65 7@C 6G6CJ H66<]k^Am

kAm“x <6AE 36:?8 >25 2E >JD6=7 7@C ?@E AFD9:?8[” w2=6GJ D2:5] “qFE ?@H x C62=:K6 E92E :E’D ;FDE E96 AC@8C2>]”k^Am

kAmp4C@DD !9:=256=A9:2[ J@F?8 <:5D =:<6 y@D9F2 2C6 H2:E:?8 >@?E9D 2?5 D@>6E:>6D J62CD 7@C 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? D6CG:46D E92E E96J 2C6 =682==J 6?E:E=65 E@[ 244@C5:?8 E@ 72>:=:6D[ E96C2AJ AC@G:56CD[ 2?5 25G@42E6D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]492=<362E]@C8^Qmr92=<362Ek^2m DA@<6 H:E9]k^Am

kAmu656C2= =2H DE2E6D E92E 2 49:=5 >FDE C646:G6 D6CG:46D 2D D@@? 2D A@DD:3=6 27E6C 2? 6G2=F2E:@? E62> 4@>A=6E6D E96:C x?5:G:5F2=:K65 t5F42E:@? !C@8C2>[ @C xt!] !6??DJ=G2?:2 92D :?E6CAC6E65 E92E E@ >62? `c 52JD] qFE @?6 AC@G:56C D2:5 E96 =:DE D96 42? 2446DD @7 49:=5C6? H2:E:?8 7@C DA6649 E96C2AJ — @?6 @7 D6G6C2= 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? D6CG:46D — :D D@>6E:>6D >@C6 E92? a[___ 72>:=:6D =@?8]k^Am

kAmt2C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? AC@G:56CD 2C6 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9649:?86CC6A@CE]@C8^D:I\:562D\E@\62D6\E96\62C=J\:?E6CG6?E:@?\DE277:?8\4C:D:D^QmF?56C DEC2:? ?2E:@?H:56k^2m[ H:E9 ?@E 6?@F89 7F?5:?8 @C DE277:?8 E@ >66E E96 ?665] qFE :? !9:=256=A9:2 — 9@>6 E@ `eT @7 E96 DE2E6’D 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? A@AF=2E:@? — @?6 A=2J6C :D =2C86=J C6DA@?D:3=6 7@C E96 DJDE6>i 2 `f_\J62C\@=5 ?@?AC@7:E 42==65 t=HJ? E92E E96 DE2E6 A2JD E@ >2?286 E96 AF3=:4=J 7F?565 AC@8C2>]k^Am

kAmpD !9:==J’D 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? DJDE6> DECF88=6D E@ >66E E96 ?665D @7 2== <:5D[ D@>6 AC@G:56CD 2?5 25G@42E6D D2J ?6:E96C t=HJ? ?@C E96 DE2E6 @77:4:2=D H9@ @G6CD66 E96 AC@8C2> 2C6 5@:?8 6?@F89 E@ 6?DFC6 <:5D 86E D6CG:46D @? E:>6]k^Am

kAmx? C6DA@?D6 E@ r92=<362E’D BF6DE:@?D[ t=HJ? !C6D:56?E 2?5 rt~ r92C=6D |4{:DE6C D2:5 t=HJ? 5@6D ?@E 4@>>6?E @? DA64:7:4 42D6D[ 3FE E96 @C82?:K2E:@? H@C<D BF:4<=J E@ 2DD6DD 49:=5C6? 2?5 AC@G:56 E96> H:E9 D6CG:46D] “u@C E96 G2DE >2;@C:EJ @7 42D6D[ D6CG:46D 2C6 AC@G:565 H:E9:? E96 567:?65 H:?5@H[” D2:5 |4{:DE6C]k^Am

kAmqFE |4{:DE6C 24<?@H=65865 E92E E96C6 42? 36 56=2JD 5F6 E@ 72>:=J 4@>>F?:42E:@?[ EC2?DA@CE2E:@?[ D4965F=:?8[ AC@G:56C 2G2:=23:=:EJ[ 2?5 D6G6C6 DE277:?8 D9@CE286D 24C@DD E96 D64E@C]k^Am

kAmtC:? y2>6D[ AC6DD D64C6E2CJ 2E E96 !6??DJ=G2?:2 s6A2CE>6?E @7 t5F42E:@?[ D2:5 :? 2 DE2E6>6?E E92E E96 56A2CE>6?E DE2JD :? 4=@D6 4@?E24E H:E9 t=HJ? E9C@F89@FE E96 J62C “E@ C6>:?5 E96> @7 E96:C =682= @3=:82E:@?D]”k^Am

kAmy2>6D 5:5 ?@E C6DA@?5 E@ BF6DE:@?D 23@FE D6CG:46 56=2JD 7@C !9:=256=A9:2 72>:=:6D] w@H6G6C[ D96 ?@E65 E92E 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? AC@8C2>D @7E6? =24< DF77:4:6?E C6D@FC46D] “rFCC6?E 7F?5:?8 =6G6=D 7@C tx ,62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@?. D6CG:46D 2C6 ?@E DF77:4:6?E 3642FD6 E96 A@AF=2E:@? @7 DEF56?ED H9@ BF2=:7J 7@C tx D6CG:46D 92D 366? :?4C62D:?8 7@C J62CD[” y2>6D D2:5]k^Am

k7:8FC6mk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]DE24<6C]4@>^H^`ag_^:>286D^DE@C:6D^a_ad^``^a`^492=<362E\72:=:?8\@FC\<:5D\`];A8Q 2=ElQtIE6C:@C G:6H @7 3C:4< H2== H:E9 D:8?286 2E t=HJ? :? !9:=256=A9:2[ !6??DJ=G2?:2] Q DEJ=6lQH:5E9i `__TQ ^mk7:842AE:@?mr2C=J $:EC:? ^^ r92=<362Ek^7:842AE:@?mk^7:8FC6m

kAmx? !9:=256=A9:2[ E96 AC@8C2>’D 56=2JD 2C6 2 <6J C62D@? >2?J @7 E96 4:EJ’D >@DE GF=?6C23=6 <:5D 72== 369:?5 367@C6 E96J 6G6? DE2CE <:?56C82CE6?[ 25G@42E6D D2J] s2E2 7C@> 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^A6??52E2]938]ADF]65F^!F3=:4\#6A@CE:?8^t2C=J\x?E6CG6?E:@?QmAC@8C2> C6A@CEDk^2m E96 DE2E6 AF3=:D96D D9@HD !9:==J 49:=5C6? :? 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? AC@8C2>D =28 369:?5 E96:C A66CD 6=D6H96C6 :? <6J 8C@HE9 2C62D[ =:<6 56G6=@A:?8 D@4:2=\6>@E:@?2= D<:==D]k^Am

kAm“%96 H9@=6 :562 @7 92G:?8 E@ H2:E >@C6 E92? E96 C6BF:C65 E:>6 :D C62==J AFEE:?8 <:5D 2E 2 5:D25G2?E286[” D2:5 x?6==2 #2J[ 5:C64E@C @7 A2C6?E 25G@424J 2?5 6?8286>6?E 2E E96 25G@424J @C82?:K2E:@? r9:=5C6? u:CDE] “q642FD6 H96? <:5D 5@?’E 92G6 E96 DFAA@CE E92E E96J ?665[ :? E@52J’D 4FCC6?E 65F42E:@? @C 6?G:C@?>6?E[ E96J 86E AFD965 @FE]”k^Am

k9bm!2C6?ED 7246 56=2JD 2446DD:?8 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? D6CG:46Dk^9bm

kAmt2C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? :D A2CE @7 E96 =2?5>2C< x?5:G:5F2=D H:E9 s:D23:=:E:6D t5F42E:@? p4E[ H9:49 5:4E2E6D E92E 2== 49:=5C6? H:E9 5:D23:=:E:6D >FDE 92G6 2446DD E@ 2 7C66 2?5 2AAC@AC:2E6 AF3=:4 65F42E:@?] %9@F89 6249 DE2E6 4C62E6D 2?5 >2?286D :ED @H? AC@8C2>[ 2== <:5D E9C@F89 286 7:G6 H9@ 2C6 :56?E:7:65 2D 92G:?8 2 56G6=@A>6?E2= 56=2J @C 5:D23:=:EJ 2C6 6=:8:3=6]k^Am

kAmx? !6??DJ=G2?:2[ E96 s6A2CE>6?E @7 t5F42E:@? @G6CD66D =@42= 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? AC@8C2>D 7@C AC6D49@@=\286 <:5D] x? 2=>@DE 6G6CJ 4@F?EJ[ 72>:=:6D 86E 4@??64E65 H:E9 D6CG:46D E9C@F89 2? :?E6C>65:2CJ F?:E[ 2 <:?5 @7 C68:@?2= 65F42E:@? D6CG:46 286?4J]k^Am

kAmqFE :? !9:=256=A9:2[ E9:?8D H@C< 5:776C6?E=J] %96 DE2E6 A2JD t=HJ? 2 4@>3:?2E:@? @7 DE2E6 2?5 7656C2= 5@==2CD E@ 25>:?:DE6C E96 4:EJ’D AC6D49@@= 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? AC@8C2>[ 2=@?8 H:E9 2 >F49 D>2==6C AC@8C2> :? r96DE6C] {2DE 7:D42= J62C[ :ED 4@?EC24E H2D H@CE9 2C@F?5 Sh_ >:==:@?] t=HJ? :D :? 492C86 @7 2DD6DD:?8 49:=5C6?[ 56G6=@A:?8 E96:C xt!D[ 2?5 DF34@?EC24E:?8 H:E9 2 ?6EH@C< @7 AC@G:56CD 7@C D6CG:46D E96J BF2=:7J 7@C]k^Am

kAm(96? w2=6GJ’D <:5D’ AC6D49@@= D2:5 96C D@? ?66565 2? 2:56[ E96 AC6D49@@= @H?6C 82G6 w2=6GJ 25G:46i !9@?6 t=HJ?] $@ D96 5:5[ 2?5 D96 H2D C6=:6G65 H96? E96 @C82?:K2E:@? E@=5 96C E96J 4@F=5 7:E y@D9F2 :? E@ 368:? 9:D 6G2=F2E:@? =2E6C E92E H66<]k^Am

kAm%92E H2D yF=J a_ac] $96 9@A65 y@D9F2 H@F=5 92G6 D6CG:46D :? E:>6 E@ 36 324< 2E AC6D49@@= 3J E96 7@==@H:?8 $6AE6>36C] qFE D@@?[ w2=6GJ D2:5 D96 3682? 9:EE:?8 C@253=@4<D]k^Am

kAmx? pF8FDE[ D96 D2:5 D96 5:5?’E 962C >F49 7C@> t=HJ?] {:<6 @E96C 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? AC@8C2>D DE2E6H:56[ t=HJ? @7E6? E2<6D 2 EH@\H66< D6CG:46 3C62< 2E E96 6?5 @7 DF>>6C — @?6 @7 >2?J D4965F=65 3C62< A6C:@5D 5FC:?8 E96 J62C]k^Am

kAmqFE E96?[ H96? D96 5:5 962C 324< E92E $6AE6>36C[ D96 =62C?65 t=HJ? H@F=5?’E 4@?D:56C AC@G:5:?8 2 @?6\E@\@?6 2:56 H:E9@FE @3D6CG:?8 y@D9F2 :? 9:D 65F42E:@?2= 6?G:C@?>6?E] qFE E96 AC6D49@@= D2:5 96 4@F=5?’E C6EFC? E@ 4=2DD F?=6DD 96 925 D@>6@?6 E96C6 E@ DA64:7:42==J DFAA@CE 9:>]k^Am

kAmpE E96 6?5 @7 $6AE6>36C[ H96? 6G2=F2E@CD HC@E6 y@D9F2’D :?:E:2= xt![ E96J 5@4F>6?E65 E92E E96J 5:D4FDD65 255:?8 2? 2:56 E@ 2DD:DE y@D9F2 2E AC6D49@@=] qFE E96J HC@E6 E92E 3642FD6 E96J 4@F=5 ?@E @3D6CG6 y@D9F2 :? 9:D 65F42E:@?2= 6?G:C@?>6?E[ E96J 5:5 ?@E 92G6 6?@F89 :?7@C>2E:@? E@ DFAA@CE E92E C64@>>6?52E:@?] “,%.96 72>:=J :D :? 2 5:77:4F=E A@D:E:@?[” E96 E62> HC@E6 @? E96 xt![ H9:49 r92=<362E 92D C6G:6H65]k^Am

kAmy@D9F2’D xt! DE2E6D E92E 96 D9@F=5 C646:G6 @44FA2E:@?2= E96C2AJ 2?5 DA64:2=:K65 :?DECF4E:@? 6249 H66<] %96 =2H C6BF:C6D D6CG:46D E@ 368:? H:E9:? `c 52JD] qFE >@C6 E92? 2 >@?E9 27E6C[ y@D9F2 DE:== H2D?’E C646:G:?8 D6CG:46D[ w2=6GJ D2:5]k^Am

kAmpE E96 E:>6[ w2=6GJ H2D DEC6E4965 E9:?] $96 H2D 2=D@ H@C<:?8 E@ 86E D6CG:46D 7@C 96C EH@\J62C\@=5 52F89E6C[ H9@ DECF88=65 H:E9 DA6649[ E9C@F89 E96 D6A2C2E6 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? AC@8C2> E92E D6CG6D 49:=5C6? FA E@ 286 E9C66[ CF? 3J E96 4:EJ]k^Am

kAmu@C w2=6GJ[ D@CE:?8 @FE 96C 52F89E6C’D D6CG:46D :? E96 3:CE9\E@\E9C66 AC@8C2> H2D D:>A=6] $6CG:46 AC@G:56CD BF:4<=J 3682? 4@?E24E:?8 96C[ 2?5 E96C2A:DED DE2CE65 D9@H:?8 FA 7@C D6DD:@?D] qFE 7@C 96C D@?[ ?@E9:?8]k^Am

kAm“~?6 52J[ x’> =:<6[ ‘~9 >J 8@D9[ H92E’D 8@:?8 @? H:E9 y@D9n’ 2?5 x DE2CE 42==:?8 6G6CJ ?F>36C x 925 2E t=HJ?[” D2:5 w2=6GJ]k^Am

kAmxE H2D?’E F?E:= EH@ >@C6 >@?E9D =2E6C[ :? }@G6>36C[ E92E 96 7:?2==J 3682? E@ C646:G6 @44FA2E:@?2= E96C2AJ[ D96 D2:5 C646?E=J 27E6C C6G:6H:?8 E6IE >6DD286D] x? s646>36C[ D96 D2:5 9:D DA64:2= :?DECF4E:@? 3682?]k^Am

k9bmt2C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? xt!D ?@E 2=H2JD 7@==@H65k^9bm

kAmt=HJ?’D !9:=256=A9:2 AC@8C2> :D E96 =2C86DE :? E96 DE2E6[ D6CG:?8 2C@F?5 ``[___ AC6D49@@=\286 49:=5C6?[ 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^A6??52E2]938]ADF]65F^A6??52E2^5@4F>6?ED^!C6D49@@=0tx0!C@8C2>^!2CETa_q^a_ab\a_ac^$A64650s2E20!C@7:=60tx0|be0u:?2=]A57Qm>@DE C646?E 52E2k^2m 7C@> E96 a_ab\ac D49@@= J62C] %96 @C82?:K2E:@? 7:CDE H@? :ED 4@?EC24E 7@C 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? D6CG:46D :? !9:=256=A9:2 :? `hhg]k^Am

kAmqFE :ED @FE4@>6D 7@C <:5D 2C6 369:?5 E96 C6DE @7 !6??DJ=G2?:2]k^Am

kAm%96 DE2E6 C6BF:C6D 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? AC@8C2>D E@ C6A@CE 52E2 @? 9@H <:5D AC@8C6DD :? 46CE2:? 2C62D[ =:<6 D@4:2=\6>@E:@?2= =62C?:?8 2?5 24BF:C:?8 ?6H D<:==D] k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^A6??52E2]938]ADF]65F^A6??52E2^5@4F>6?ED^!C6D49@@=0tx0!C@8C2>^!2CETa_q^a_ab\a_ac^$A64650s2E20!C@7:=60tx0|be0u:?2=]A57Qm$E2E6 AC@8C2> C6A@CEDk^2m D9@H E92E 7@C E96 =2DE 7:G6 J62CD @7 52E2[ 49:=5C6? :? t=HJ?’D !9:=256=A9:2 AC@8C2> 92G6 366? =6DD =:<6=J E@ AC@8C6DD :? 2== E9C66 8C@HE9 42E68@C:6D 4@>A2C65 H:E9 E96 DE2E6 2G6C286]k^Am

kAm|2C8:6 (2<6=:?[ 2 D6?:@C 2EE@C?6J 2E E96 !6??DJ=G2?:2\32D65 t5F42E:@? {2H r6?E6C[ D2:5 96C E62> 92D 2DD:DE65 >@C6 E92? g_ !9:=256=A9:2 72>:=:6D :? E96 =2DE J62C H9@D6 <:5D’ 65F42E:@? H2D 5:DCFAE65 2E =62DE :? A2CE 3642FD6 E96J 4@F=5?’E 2446DD 2AAC@AC:2E6 D6CG:46D 7C@> t=HJ?] %96 G2DE >2;@C:EJ @7 E9@D6 49:=5C6?[ D96 D2:5[ H6C6 q=24< 2?5 qC@H? <:5D 27764E65 3J A@G6CEJ]k^Am

kAm$@>6 72>:=:6D 9:C6 2EE@C?6JD E@ 96=A E96> 2446DD E96 D6CG:46D E96J’C6 6?E:E=65 E@[ @C 86E AC@ 3@?@ C6AC6D6?E2E:@? 7C@> @C82?:K2E:@?D =:<6 E96 t5F42E:@? {2H r6?E6C] |2?J H9@ H:? E96:C 42D6D 86E 4@>A6?D2E@CJ 65F42E:@?[ @7E6? :? E96 7@C> @7 >@?6J E96 72>:=J 42? FD6 E@ A2J 7@C D6CG:46D 27E6C E96 42D6 :D @G6C]k^Am

kAmqFE E92E 5@6D?’E >2<6 FA 7@C =@DE E:>6[ 2D 49:=5C6? BF:4<=J 286 @FE @7 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@?] #6D62C49 D9@HD E92E k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]492=<362E]@C8^49:428@^a_ad^_`^ab^AC6>2EFC6\323:6D\DECF88=6\E@\2446DD\62C=J\:?E6CG6?E:@?^Qm49:=5C6?’D 3C2:?D 56G6=@A >@C6 C2A:5=J 36EH66? 3:CE9 E@ 7:G6k^2m E92? 2E 2?J @E96C E:>6 @7 E96:C =:76] |2?J 72>:=:6D[ (2<6=:? D2:5[ 92G6 2=D@ 925 E96:C 49:=5C6? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]492=<362E]@C8^A9:=256=A9:2^a_a`^`a^f^aag`ch_b^A6??DJ=G2?:2\AC6D49@@=\DFDA6?D:@?D\6IAF=D:@?D\3692G:@C\4@G:5QmDFDA6?565 7C@> AC6D49@@=k^2m @C >256 E@ @?=J 2EE6?5 A2CE:2= 52JD 3642FD6 @7 E96:C 5:D23:=:E:6D]k^Am

kAm“xE’D DF49 2 4C:E:42= A6C:@5 7@C <:5D E@ 92G6 2446DD E@ 9:89\BF2=:EJ 65F42E:@?[” D2:5 (2<6=:?] p DJDE6> E92E :56?E:7:6D 49:=5C6? 2D ?665:?8 D6CG:46D 3FE 5@6D?’E 7@==@H E9C@F89[ D96 25565[ :D “C62==J 72:=:?8 @FC <:5D]”’k^Am

kAm|4{:DE6C[ t=HJ?’D rt~[ D2:5 E96 @C82?:K2E:@? 92D =62C?65 E92E[ :? D@>6 42D6D[ 49:=5C6? 2C6 DFDA6?565 7C@> E96:C AC6D49@@= AC@8C2>D 3642FD6 @7 =62C?:?8 @C 3692G:@C2= ?665D] “t=HJ? :D ?@E A2CE @7 E9:D 564:D:@?\>2<:?8 2?5 @7E6? =62C?D 23@FE :E 27E6C E96 724E[” 96 D2:5] w6 25565 E92E E96 @C82?:K2E:@? :D 56G6=@A:?8 E@@=D “E92E H:== 96=A FD F?56CDE2?5 E96 7C6BF6?4J :? H9:49 E9:D 92AA6?D” 2?5 :D 4C62E:?8 255:E:@?2= C6D@FC46 >2E6C:2=D 7@C 72>:=:6D]k^Am

kAm$E2E6 C6A@CED D9@H E92E t=HJ?’D AC@8C2> :D DF446DD7F= :? D@>6 2C62D[ =:<6 6G2=F2E:?8 hfT @7 <:5D H:E9:? e_ 52JD[ E96 DE2E6\C6BF:C65 E:>6=:?6] qFE E92E’D ;FDE E96 7:CDE DE6A :? H92E 25G@42E6D D2J @7E6? 364@>6D 2 >@?E9\=@?8 AC@46DD E@ 86E D6CG:46D]k^Am

kAm%9@F89 E96 =2H :D 4=62C E92E <:5D D9@F=5 C646:G6 D6CG:46D H:E9:? `c 52JD @7 E96:C xt! 36:?8 HC:EE6?[ E96 DE2E6 5@6D ?@E AF3=:D9 :?7@C>2E:@? @? 9@H =@?8 <:5D H2:E 7@C D6CG:46D 27E6C 2? 6G2=F2E:@?[ @C 9@H >2?J D6CG:46 :?E6CCFAE:@?D E96J’== 6IA6C:6?46 H96? AC@G:56CD 2C6 ?@ =@?86C 2G2:=23=6]k^Am

kAm(96? :E 4@>6D E@ t=HJ?’D A6C7@C>2?46[ rt~ |4{:DE6C D2:5 E92E DEF56?ED’ 8C@HE9 52E2 5@6D ?@E 244@F?E 7@C E96 F?:BF6 492==6?86D @7 AC@G:5:?8 D6CG:46D :? !9:=256=A9:2] %96 49:=5C6? t=HJ? D6CG6D 92G6 9:896C ?665D E92? E96 DE2E6 2G6C286[ 96 D2:5[ H:E9 9:896C :?4:56?46D @7 56G6=@A>6?E2= 56=2JD 2?5 2 8C62E6C AC6G2=6?46 @7 >F=E:A=6 @E96C 492==6?86D[ DF49 2D =:>:E65 t?8=:D9 AC@7:4:6?4J[ 64@?@>:4 5:D25G2?E286D[ 2?5 @E96C D@4:2= C:D< 724E@CD]k^Am

kAm“u@C J@F?86C 49:=5C6?[ E96D6 724E@CD AC@5F46 >@C6 >@56DE 82:?D[” D2:5 |4{:DE6C]k^Am

kAm|4{:DE6C 6>A92D:K65 E92E t=HJ? 92D 366? DF446DD7F= :? 6G2=F2E:?8 E96 G2DE >2;@C:EJ @7 49:=5C6? @? E:>6[ 2?5 D2:5 E96 >@DE 4@>>@? C62D@? 2? 6G2=F2E:@? 72==D @FED:56 E96 e_\52J H:?5@H :D 2 A2C6?E 42?46==:?8 2? :?:E:2= 6G2=F2E:@? 2AA@:?E>6?E 2?5 ?665:?8 :E E@ 36 C6D4965F=65]k^Am

kAmw6 D2:5 56=2JD :? 86EE:?8 <:5DV D6CG:46D 2C6 @7E6? E96 C6DF=E @7 D4965F=:?8 492==6?86D 2?5 DE277:?8 D9@CE286D — hdT @7 D6CG:46 :DDF6D C6=2E65 E@ DA6649 2?5 =2?8F286 D6CG:46D[ 96 D2:5[ 2C6 5F6 E@ 2 =24< @7 DE277] w6 D2:5 @E96C 56=2JD @44FC H96? 72>:=:6D >@G6 @C 492?86 E96:C 49:=5’D AC6D49@@= 6?C@==>6?E[ 2?5 H96? AC@G:56CD C6EFC? <:5D E@ E96 “?665D =:DE[” >62?:?8 E96J DE@A D6CG:46 7@C E92E 49:=5[ H9:49 92AA6?D “7@C 2 G2C:6EJ @7 C62D@?D]”k^Am

kAmu@C y@D9F2[ 86EE:?8 2 4@?D:DE6?E DA64:2= :?DECF4E@C[ 2 A@D:E:@? >62?E E@ DFAA@CE y@D9F2’D =62C?:?8[ 92D 366? :>A@DD:3=6[ w2=6GJ D2:5] w6C E6IE 9:DE@CJ[ H9:49 D96 C6G:6H65 C646?E=J[ 5@4F>6?ED E96 492==6?86Di %96 7:CDE DA64:2= :?DECF4E@C H9@ 4@?E24E65 96C ?6G6C G:D:E65 2?5 DE@AA65 C6DA@?5:?8 E@ E6IED[ D96 D2:5] %96 ?6IE A6CD@? H2D >@C6 96=A7F= 2?5 D2H y@D9F2 2 76H E:>6D[ 3FE E96? 23CFAE=J BF:E] }@H[ 27E6C >@C6 E92? 2 >@?E9 @7 ?@ DA64:2= :?DECF4E:@?[ 2 ?6H AC@G:56C 4@>6D >@DE=J C68F=2C=J[ w2=6GJ D2:5]k^Am

kAmp446DD E@ @44FA2E:@?2= E96C2AJ 92D 366? D=:89E=J 36EE6C[ w2=6GJ D2:5] u@C E96 7:CDE D6G6C2= >@?E9D @7 D6CG:46[ y@D9F2’D @44FA2E:@?2= E96C2A:DE D9@H65 FA :?4@?D:DE6?E=J 2?5 D66>65 CFD965[ w2=6GJ D2:5] }@H[ 27E6C H@C<:?8 @FE 2 D4965F=6[ D96 4@?D:DE6?E=J 4@>6D 2C@F?5 @?46 2 H66<]k^Am

k9bmt2C=J 49:=59@@5 :?E6CG6?E:@? ?665D >@C6 7F?5:?8[ D@>6 D2Jk^9bm

kAm%96D6 2?5 @E96C 492==6?86D 2C6?’E F?:BF6 E@ !9:=256=A9:2 72>:=:6D] qFE AC6D49@@= @A6C2E@CD 2?5 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? AC@G:56CD D2J E96C6 2C6 A2CE:4F=2C 2?5 =@?8DE2?5:?8 AC@3=6>D :? !9:==J]k^Am

kAm%H@ J62CD 28@[ $92C@? }6:=D@?[ 7@C>6C 5:C64E@C @7 E96 (@@5=2?5 p4256>J r9:=5 s6G6=@A>6?E r6?E6C :? (6DE !9:=256=A9:2[ H2D A2CE @7 2 8C@FA AFD9:?8 E@ 3C:?8 2EE6?E:@? E@ AC@3=6>D :? E96 4:EJ’D 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? AC@8C2>] r@F?4:= >6>36CD k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^49:=5C6?7:CDEA2]@C8^?6HD^E6DE:>@?J\A9:=256=A9:2\4:EJ\4@F?4:=\62C=J\:?E6CG6?E:@?\D6CG:46D^Qm96=5 2 962C:?8k^2m 23@FE A2C6?ED’ 492==6?86D 2446DD:?8 D6CG:46D[ 2?5 }6:=D@? 2?5 @E96C AC@G:56CD >6E H:E9 t=HJ?]k^Am

kAmpE E96 E:>6[ }6:=D@? D2:5[ D96 H2D 9@A67F= E92E E9:?8D H@F=5 :>AC@G6] qFE D:?46 E96?[ D96 D2:5[ “H6’G6 24EF2==J D66? :E 86E H@CD6]”k^Am

kAm}6:=D@?[ H9@ ?@H H@C<D 2D DFAA@CE DE277 2E (@@5=2?5 p4256>J[ D2:5 @7 E96 aa 49:=5C6? 6?C@==65 2E E96 AC6D49@@=[ 23@FE 7@FC 4FCC6?E=J C646:G6 D6CG:46D 7C@> t=HJ?[ 2?5 E9C66 >@C6 2C6 8@:?8 E9C@F89 E96 AC@46DD @7 86EE:?8 6G2=F2E65]k^Am

kAm%96 AC6D49@@= 96=AD 72>:=:6D ?2G:82E6 E96 AC@46DD[ :? A2CE 3642FD6 DF3>:EE:?8 C6BF:C65 A2A6CH@C< 2?5 D4965F=:?8 6G2=F2E:@?D 42? 4C62E6 255:E:@?2= 32CC:6CD[ D96 D2:5] qFE 6G6? H:E9 255:E:@?2= 96=A[ :? 96C 6IA6C:6?46 :E DE:== FDF2==J E2<6D >@?E9D 7@C <:5D E@ 36 6G2=F2E65 2?5 D6CG:46D E@ 368:?[ D96 D2:5]k^Am

kAm“x E9:?< E92E’D E96 D2556DE E9:?8 7@C >6[” }6:=D@? D2:5] “%96 72>:=:6D 2C6 G6CJ 7CFDEC2E65 3642FD6 E96J 5@?’E <?@H H92E E@ 5@ — E96J ;FDE <?@H E92E E96J ?665 96=A 7@C E96:C 49:=5[ 3FE :E’D ;FDE G6CJ 92C5 E@ ?2G:82E6]”k^Am

kAm~77:4:2=D D2J 2 =24< @7 C6D@FC46D :D =2C86=J E@ 3=2>6] ~G6C E96 A2DE 564256[ E96 ?F>36C @7 AC6D49@@=\286 49:=5C6? :? !6??DJ=G2?:2 C646:G:?8 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? D6CG:46D 92D 8C@H? 3J 2 E9:C5[ 2?5 7F?5:?8 92D?’E <6AE FA]k^Am

kAm!6??DJ=G2?:2 s6A2CE>6?E @7 t5F42E:@? DA@<6DA6CD@? tC:? y2>6D D2:5 E92E :D H9J v@G] y@D9 $92A:C@ AC@A@D65 :?4C62D:?8 7F?5:?8 7@C AC6D49@@= 62C=J :?E6CG6?E:@? 3J S`c]d >:==:@? :? E96 DE2E6 3F586E] w@H6G6C[ >@?E9D A2DE E96 3F586E 5625=:?6[ =2H>2<6CD C6>2:? 2E 2? :>A2DD6 @G6C E96 3F586E 2?5 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]492=<362E]@C8^A9:=256=A9:2^a_ad^`_^`_^A6??DJ=G2?:2\3F586E\56=2J\DEC2:?D\AC6D49@@=\AC@G:56CD^Qm62C=J 65F42E:@? AC@G:56CD 2C6 7FCE96C DEC2:?65k^2m]k^Am

kAm~?6 AC@G:56C H9@ 4@?EC24ED H:E9 t=HJ? D2:5 4@?46C?:?8 :?6BF:E:6D 6I:DE :? t=HJ?’D AC@8C2>] Wr92=<362E :D ?@E ?2>:?8 E96 AC@G:56C 5F6 E@ 96C 762CD @7 C6E2=:2E:@? 7C@> t=HJ?]X xE’D 2? 2446AE65 ?@C>[ E96 AC@G:56C D2:5[ E92E <:5D :? ?:46C ?6:893@C9@@5D 86E A:4<65 FA 7@C D6CG:46 >F49 72DE6C E92? E9@D6 :? A@@C6C ?6:893@C9@@5D]k^Am

kAm“%96C6’D 2? 2446DD 2?5 6BF:EJ :DDF6 24C@DD E96 3@2C5[” D2:5 E96 AC@G:56C] “p?5 E92E’D 6I246C32E65 3J E96 D9@CE286 @7 AC@G:56CD]”k^Am

kAmpD<65 23@FE E9@D6 2446DD 2?5 6BF:EJ 4@?46C?D[ |4{:DE6C D2:5 E92E E@ 255C6DD D@>6 C6=2E65 492==6?86D[ E9:D J62C t=HJ? :D :>A=6>6?E:?8 >@C6 E2C86E65 EC2:?:?8 7@C DE277 2?5 A=2?D E@ 56G6=@A 2 72>:=J C6D@FC46 46?E6C] w6 D2:5 E96 @C82?:K2E:@? 92D 2=D@ 6>A=@J65 :?E6C?2= DA6649 =2?8F286 A2E9@=@8:DED E@ 2DD:8? E@ 9:89\AC:@C:EJ 42D6D]k^Am

kAm(96? 72>:=:6D C6249 @FE E@ t=HJ?[ |4{:DE6C D2:5 DE277 AC@G:56 E96> H:E9 5@4F>6?E2E:@? 2?5 G6C32= 6IA=2?2E:@?D @7 9@H E96 AC@46DD H@C<D E@ 6?DFC6 72>:=:6D F?56CDE2?5 E96:C C:89ED[ ?6IE DE6AD[ 2?5 9@H E@ 8:G6 4@?D6?E 7@C 6G2=F2E:@?D]k^Am

kAm%96 @C82?:K2E:@? 2=D@ A6C:@5:42==J ?@E:7:6D AC@G:56CD @7 9:DE@C:42==J F?56CD6CG65 +x! 4@56D E@ 6?4@FC286 AC@G:56CD E@ D6CG6 <:5D 6BF:E23=J 24C@DD E96 4:EJ[ 2?5 :?4=F56D AC@G:D:@?D :? :ED 4@?EC24ED >62?E E@ “AC@>@E6 72:C?6DD 2?5 244@F?E23:=:EJ]” |4{:DE6C D2:5 t=HJ? A=246D DF34@?EC24E@CD @? 4@CC64E:G6 24E:@? A=2?D :7 E96 @C82?:K2E:@? “56E64ED A2EE6C?D @7 ?@?\2446AE2?46 E92E 5:DAC@A@CE:@?2E6=J :>A24ED F?56CD6CG65 2C62D]”k^Am

kAmpD 7@C w2=6GJ[ D96 D2JD 96C 72>:=J 92D 8@EE6? C6=2E:G6=J =F4<J] %96J H6C6 23=6 E@ 86E y@D9F2 DE2CE65 @? 2? 6G2=F2E:@? BF:4<=J] p?5 D96’D 366? 23=6 E@ 86E ?6H E96C2A:DED H96? @E96CD DE@A D9@H:?8 FA]k^Am

kAmqFE 96C 72>:=J’D 3:886DE A:646 @7 =F4<[ D96 D2:5[ :D E92E 96C 9FD32?5 C646?E=J 8@E 2 ?6H ;@3 H:E9 36EE6C 962=E9 :?DFC2?46] $96 A=2?D E@ FD6 E92E E@ 86E D@>6 @7 E96 D6CG:46D 96C <:5D ?665] %92E >62?D D96 ?@ =@?86C H:== 4@>A=6E6=J C6=J @? t=HJ?]k^Am

kAm$96 ;FDE H:D96D D96 4@F=5 6C2D6 E96 >@?E9D @7 H2:E:?8 2?5 H@CCJ:?8 23@FE H9J y@D9F2’D D6CG:46D E@@< D@ =@?8 E@ DE2CE]k^Am

kAm“q2D:42==J[ H92E 92AA6?65 :D H6 76== E9C@F89 E96 4C24<D[” D96 D2:5]k^Am

kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]492=<362E]@C8^A9:=256=A9:2^a_ad^`_^a_^<:5D\6IA6C:6?46\62C=J\:?E6CG6?E:@?\56=2JD\:?\6=HJ?\AC@8C2>^Qmk6>m%9:D DE@CJk^6>mk^2m k6>mH2D AC@5F465 3Jk^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]492=<362E]@C8Qmk6>mr92=<362Ek^6>mk^2m k6>m2?5 C6G:6H65 2?5 5:DEC:3FE65 3Jk^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9F3D]=2^"_b<=8$#_Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQmk6>m$E24<6Ck^6>mk^2m]k^Am